Home » Live beef and sheep exports – enough is enough – The Good Oil by Rod Brown

Live beef and sheep exports – enough is enough – The Good Oil by Rod Brown

Let’s face it. Shipping live animals in cramped pens for long distances across tropical seas is inherently cruel. And a good number of these beasts then face further suffering on arrival.

Around 50 percent of Australia’s sheep and seven percent of its cattle are exported live. This is a clear failure of our agriculture and industry policy, and it’s heartening to see the number of farmers now joining the swelling ranks of activists for export bans on live shipments.

You must have sympathy for Agriculture Minister Joe Ludwig, who brought in a temporary export ban but was soon overruled because of the huge political storm it created. The reason, of course, is the fact that live exports have been the lifeline of the northern beef farmers and many sheep farmers through some very difficult times, and they simply will not countenance unions or anyone else threatening their commercial lifeline into Asia.

As a result, it’s one of the most political of all industries and very resistant to change – the key reason for our inability to turn beef and sheep commodities into high-value foods.

So we’ve been kicking around some ideas here in Canberra about an Action Plan to value-add beef and sheep through greater local processing. We figure it is both commonsense and totally consistent with the values of a Labor government. Accordingly, we are proposing to build a collaborative joint venture ‘model’ for Minister Ludwig’s consideration.

I can’t go into detail here, but the plan would basically apply this model to certain abattoirs in Australia. They would need to have progressive management that is amenable to working with unions, farmers and extension agencies to significantly lower costs at critical points along the supply chain.

We figure that co-investment with enlightened foreign investors would also be smart in order to address some of the overseas market constraints. This is not rocket science – a group of us here in Canberra worked on the Button industry plans for steel, passenger motor vehicles, building and construction, and textiles, footwear and clothing. The issues are not that different.

If your council is interested in being involved, please contact me ASAP.

NEIS – helping budding entrepreneurs

The official unemployment rate of 5.4 percent is a mystery given the grim stories we’re hearing about jobs disappearing out from under young adults. The official figure surely disguises a lot of part-time employment as well as creative accounting.

It therefore wasn’t surprising when I was approached by a group of out-of-work young professionals recently. They wanted a steer on setting up their own businesses because, although they were optimistic about eventually landing a job, they were not looking forward to being treated like mice on a treadmill. And they were complaining that a formal job would interfere with their overseas trips!

My initial advice was Malcolm Fraser-ish — life wasn’t meant to be easy. But after tossing around ideas with them, we agreed that if they are hell-bent on setting up their own business, they would need to find people who can guide and mentor them, without walking off with their ideas.

A faint bell began ringing. We’d remembered good things about the New Enterprise Incentive Scheme (NEIS). So after some googling and a few phone calls we were reacquainted with the fact that NEIS is for job seekers interested in starting and running a small business.

Accredited small business training is provided as well as advice and mentoring. Ongoing income support for up to 52 weeks, plus rental allowance in certain circumstances, is also paid.

The income support is around $490/week, which is about double the unemployment benefit. And during the training, the budding entrepreneurs develop a business plan and the local NEIS provider then helps them put the business plan into practice.

So if you have an unemployed son, daughter, relation or friend wanting to have a go, just google ‘New Enterprise Incentive Scheme’ for details.
Australian Sports Foundation

The ASF is a non-profit organisation set up by the federal government to assist not-for-profit groups raise money for eligible sports projects.
The way the program works is that organisations apply for tax deductibility status for donations towards specific projects. These projects must: be sport related; increase opportunities for Australians to participate in or excel in sport; be financially viable.

Eligible organisations include sporting clubs, schools, government organisations and community groups.

The particular value of the ASF program is that it provides a good angle for attracting company sponsorship into local projects, which in turn improves your pitch for federal and state grants: i.e. proving that there is strong community support for the project. Contact us for further advice.

In support of ROCs

I sense that numerous local councils are forgetting about the importance of regional organisations of councils (ROCs). They are focusing their lobbying effort instead on an annual trip to Canberra for the ALGA Congress and an occasional meeting with their local federal MP.

This is a shame, because a strong ROC is invariably the best means of engaging federal agencies on key projects and issues. The rationale is that a ROC provides councils with a sharper, more deliberate vehicle for engagement than by going it alone or by filtering their agendas through bigger organisations. There are other benefits:

  • Councils, individually and collectively, develop collaborative skills. This increases their ongoing ability to deal with federal and state ministers and officials;
  • Councils get almost immediate feedback, thus reducing delays and confusion over who said what and why;
  • Councils and the region develop a reputation as serious players. This opens doors in Canberra.

A great example of a strong ROC is the Eastern Metropolitan Regional Council in Perth, which is an incorporated body under the WA Local Government Act. It has a healthy cash flow by virtue of its ownership of a waste management facility, a solid core of expertise not only in waste management but also in regional development, advocacy and environmental services. It also has credibility with both the WA and federal governments, and a host of infrastructure projects that it’s currently either managing or making inputs into.

Another example of a strong ROC is the South East Australia Transport Strategy Inc. (SEATS). It was formed in the mid 1990s as a lobby group of some 15 local councils between Dandenong and Wollongong — the main game was to get SpeedRail going via the eastern seaboard. But the agenda broadened out to numerous other projects that did happen such as the Bombala bridges and the Eden Wharf to name just two.

Rod Brown is a Canberra-based consultant specialising in
industry/regional development, investment attraction, clusters and
accessing Federal grants. He also runs the Cockatoo Network. He can be
contacted at apdcockatoo@iprimus.com.au or phone (02) 6231 7261. Go to the blog at www.investmentinnovation.wordpress.com for 550+ articles on issues relevant to Local Government.

Digital Editions


  • Lockyer send flood expert north

    Lockyer send flood expert north

    Lockyer Valley Regional Council has answered the call for assistance from a community impacted by Ex-Tropical Cyclone Koji, with a staff member from Council’s Disaster…

More News

  • Lockyer announce Scott Greensill as CEO

    Lockyer announce Scott Greensill as CEO

    Lockyer Valley Regional Council has appointed Scott Greensill as its new Chief Executive Officer. Councillors formally approved the appointment of Mr Greensill at a Special Meeting of Council in February.…

  • Myers resigns for health reasons

    Myers resigns for health reasons

    Wollongong’s Councillor Tiana Myers has resigned, as a Ward Three Councillor for City Council due to health reasons. Cr Myers was elected to Council in 2024 with a focus on…

  • Acknowledging women’s role in councils

    Acknowledging women’s role in councils

    Council representatives from across the state gathered in Sydney today for Local Government NSW’s (LGNSW) International Women’s Day event. Mayor Darcy Byrne, President of LGNSW, said the event was an…

  • Kylie Davies beats strong field

    Kylie Davies beats strong field

    Flinders Shire Council is pleased to announce the appointment of Kylie Davies as its new Chief Executive Officer. Ms Davies will start in the role on 13 April following a…

  • Leaving on a high

    Leaving on a high

    Mount Alexander Shire Council’s Chief Executive Officer Darren Fuzzard will end his tenure at the council in July 2026, marking ten years of service to the organisation and community. Mr…

  • Safety first for transport corridor

    Safety first for transport corridor

    Traversing a major Townsville transit corridor spanning three suburbs will soon be safer for motorists, cyclists and pedestrians, with Townsville City Council commencing a $3.8 million upgrade of Hugh and…

  • Creating long-term employment pathways

    Creating long-term employment pathways

    The Shire of Carnarvon is creating long-term employment pathways and strengthening workforce capability through its participation in the Remote Jobs and Economic Development (RJED) Program, a national initiative designed to…

  • Cool summer plan for Campbelltown

    Cool summer plan for Campbelltown

    Extreme heat is the biggest killer of natural disasters in Australia, exceeding that for any other environmental disaster combined, including floods, storms, bushfires and cyclones. While high temperatures pose risks…

  • Bathurst has it’s scrap together

    Bathurst has it’s scrap together

    Bathurst Regional Council has successfully concluded its ‘Let’s Get Our Scrap Together’ campaign, launched on 1 September 2025 with funding from the NSW Government and delivered in collaboration with NetWaste…

  • Baw Baw acting CEO tenure extended

    Baw Baw acting CEO tenure extended

    Baw Baw Shire Council has extended the contract of Acting Chief Executive Officer Sally Jones until 30 June 2026. The matter was considered as a confidential item in the late…