Home » Striking a balance between technical liability and commercial considerations*

Striking a balance between technical liability and commercial considerations*

It is often presumed that complaint resolutions necessarily involve winners and losers and that may be so in the adversarial culture of the legal system.

In the cut and thrust of everyday complaint handling however, the joint problem-solving approach has obvious commercial practical advantages.

The question of technical liability, i.e. who was at fault, is a consideration but it is not the only, nor even always the most important one in determining appropriate action in response to a complaint.

The best resolutions are usually reached by people with sufficient training, product knowledge and delegated authority to negotiate outcomes which look beyond who is ‘right’ and who is ‘wrong’.
A creative approach to remedies and resolutions focuses on the interests of both the council and the customer.

What will it cost in terms of time, money and reputation to give the complainant what they’re seeking?

If we don’t give them what they are seeking and they appeal to an external body, e.g. Ombudsman what will it cost?
How highly do we value the complainant’s goodwill?

If we’re not able to give them what they’re seeking, are there other things we might do to restore their confidence and goodwill towards us?

A good resolution is one that is negotiated directly between the customer and the council, rather than imposed by an external organisation, recognises the interests of, and is acceptable to both sides, addresses all aspects of the complaint and upholds principles of fairness, legal obligations and good industry practice.

* Copy supplied by Australian Disputes Centre

Digital Editions


  • From books to bots

    From books to bots

    Tenterfield Library is proving that technology is more than just tools and devices. From coding and robotics to tech support, the Library has become a…

More News

  • Myers resigns for health reasons

    Myers resigns for health reasons

    Wollongong’s Councillor Tiana Myers has resigned, as a Ward Three Councillor for City Council due to health reasons. Cr Myers was elected to Council in 2024 with a focus on…

  • Acknowledging women’s role in councils

    Acknowledging women’s role in councils

    Council representatives from across the state gathered in Sydney today for Local Government NSW’s (LGNSW) International Women’s Day event. Mayor Darcy Byrne, President of LGNSW, said the event was an…

  • Kylie Davies beats strong field

    Kylie Davies beats strong field

    Flinders Shire Council is pleased to announce the appointment of Kylie Davies as its new Chief Executive Officer. Ms Davies will start in the role on 13 April following a…

  • Leaving on a high

    Leaving on a high

    Mount Alexander Shire Council’s Chief Executive Officer Darren Fuzzard will end his tenure at the council in July 2026, marking ten years of service to the organisation and community. Mr…

  • Safety first for transport corridor

    Safety first for transport corridor

    Traversing a major Townsville transit corridor spanning three suburbs will soon be safer for motorists, cyclists and pedestrians, with Townsville City Council commencing a $3.8 million upgrade of Hugh and…

  • Creating long-term employment pathways

    Creating long-term employment pathways

    The Shire of Carnarvon is creating long-term employment pathways and strengthening workforce capability through its participation in the Remote Jobs and Economic Development (RJED) Program, a national initiative designed to…

  • Cool summer plan for Campbelltown

    Cool summer plan for Campbelltown

    Extreme heat is the biggest killer of natural disasters in Australia, exceeding that for any other environmental disaster combined, including floods, storms, bushfires and cyclones. While high temperatures pose risks…

  • Bathurst has it’s scrap together

    Bathurst has it’s scrap together

    Bathurst Regional Council has successfully concluded its ‘Let’s Get Our Scrap Together’ campaign, launched on 1 September 2025 with funding from the NSW Government and delivered in collaboration with NetWaste…

  • Baw Baw acting CEO tenure extended

    Baw Baw acting CEO tenure extended

    Baw Baw Shire Council has extended the contract of Acting Chief Executive Officer Sally Jones until 30 June 2026. The matter was considered as a confidential item in the late…

  • Farewell to a much-loved bridge

    Farewell to a much-loved bridge

    Narrabri Shire Council hosted a special community farewell event in mid-January, Brekkie on the Bridge, ahead of the upcoming demolition of the Violet Street Bridge. The event brought together community…